How to Use Pay by Performance with A Marketing-Advertising Agency?

Friends from the Creative industry generally lamented about being under paid and under appreciated while clients were genuinely concerned if they can recoup their investments in creative and production costs. After I published "How to Pay your Advertising Agency?" at my blog and ezinearticles, I was specifically asked if I can provide an example of Pay by Performance with a marketing agency or advertising agency.

Assuming the client has a decent agency brief and the marketing/advertising/creative agency understood it perfectly, then they actually conceptualized an equally decent campaign; theoretically there should be good returns. However, the marketplace is a strange place where big changes can speedily shoot a hot product down into the bottom of a valley. Though rare, it has happened before. It is such uncertainties of the marketplace, doubts and fears of clients and the difficulty of quantifying the value of creative people that the quotation is grounds for heated debates.

I believed a fair price is one where the client and the marketing agency agreed upon. The price can be agreed upon but unfairness somehow would still cropped up. The client might not be able to attribute his success to the press advertisement as there was no tracking device established. The designer might start to believe he has been paid peanuts when the sales results hit the roof. Even nothing was said and expressed; dissatisfaction can quietly seep in and adversely affect an otherwise cohesive working relationship.

So instead of offering or accepting a fixed price, both parties can consider the pay by performance option. To pay on results or pay by performance is not as simple as it might appear. Marketing, advertising and communications is largely a skill based, creative industry; where the products are ideas and action taken. Just as a beautiful fireworks display is over when its over, ideas exposed can never be taken back to reuse and recycle in their original forms. I am sure you can see the challenges of a pay by results program. The real costs that were tough to measure are the creative cost though it is not impossible. To effectively deploy pay by performance, you would need to overcome various challenges, and those had been discussed at another of my article, "Does Pay by Performance works with an Advertising Agency?".

After considering those factors and you still think pay by performance is for you, you may like to consider this working model.

1. Established what constitutes sunk cost, which could easily mean time (for research, analysis, brainstorming, conceptualization, copywriting, visualizing, story-boarding, desktop execution), material (such as photography with photographer, models, studio, props or purchased photo images or database for direct mail), traveling expenses.

2. Establish the quantum of such cost. Where cost cannot be quantified, you can check with your Association of Accredited Ad Agencies for recommended rates.

3. Client needs to agree to the quotation and to paying the sunk costs

4. Both parties need to agree on the performance measure. This includes fixing the deliverables and determining the expected results for each of these deliverables. One of the most obvious, and accurate, deliverable would be response to the campaign. This is usually measured by including some kind of direct response within the campaign. It could be a call-in number, an email or a web site.

5. Payment of the performance level should have a clear end date. Companies should not be afraid to pay. Alternatively, they can put a cap on the quantum, assuming that they are expecting a runaway success for the campaign. Again, this cap needs to be agreed. For example, both parties can agree to a $50,000 or a $5,000,000 cap to the performance bonus portion of the agency fees depending on the size of the project.

There are of course many ways to spin this. Above is simply one way to look at a complex arrangement. I am sure you can come up with a few creative ways to do this.

Dont worry about what it costs you, only concern yourself with WHAT IT WILL MAKE YOU !

*********************************************************

Vivienne Quek is a seasoned veteran in the advertising industry. She has worked in small local outfits to large international marketing/advertising agencies servicing multi-million dollar accounts. Today, she runs two marketing agencies providing a wide range of marketing and communications services

Vivienne continues to play an active role in her agencies and blogs to share her experiences with everyone at http://www.versacreations.net

To continue to benefit from her shared experience, VISIT HER BLOG

Media Advertising Agencies
A media advertising agency handle a variety of tasks for a client, but its main responsibility is to create the right messages to the right media outlets to project the most positive company image as possible.Media advertising agencies have a whole gamut of people who perform various specialized tasks. For example, there is a full-fledged client-se...

4 Great Tips to Selecting a Marketing or Advertising Agency
There are many times in the career of a marketing person where this issue will come up - which agency should I use? From the perspective of the advertising agency or the marketing agency, the answer is simple, "Use us!"The client is usually pressured from many quarters, among which are the pressure to deliver results, the watching eyes of everyone ...

6/10 Londoners are not of English Origin compared to 1/30 London Advertising Agency Employees - Hmmm
Ethnic marketing- There I just said it. It is not a dirty word anymore. So why is black guy Howard from the Halifax still 'entertaining' the white majority audience?The issue of marketing to diverse and multi-cultural societies in an optimum manner is something that I think is continuously carried out ineffectively with little consideration.Living...

Friday: Your Daily Yellow Page Ad Review
Its now the fifth day of your journey through your Yellow Page advertising. Youre picked a great headline, sub-head, picture, and text. Youre almost done. But there is some work ahead. Have you chosen the proper size, colors, and placement? Because of your budget constrains, you probably chose an ad based on what you could afford at the time. So le...

Debt Relief - 5 Ways To Stop Collection Agency Harassment
The FDCPA which is the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act is here to protect you from debt collection agencies and attorneys. There are very effective ways to handle debt collectors. If you feel your family or company is in danger of day to day harassment, here are 5 ways to stop bill collectors from harassing you. Receive debt relief right away.St...

Quick Debt Relief
Are you looking for quick debt relief? Debt consolidation may be the answer. Thousands of people across the country have found the light at the end of the tunnel, managed to get their financial lives back on track, and make a fresh new start, thanks to the services provided by a debt consolidation agency.As the name implies, a debt consolidation ag...

Are You Ready for Direct Response Radio Advertising?
These Six Questions Tell You How to Make the Answer YesDirect response radio advertising is an amazingly under recognized way to grow a business quickly and profitably. For one thing, it's fully accountable, so every dollar spent can be tracked to the revenue it generates and unprofitable spending can be eliminated. In addition, it's extremely scal...